Reader's questions about minority shareholders

A reader recently wrote a very good question about minority shareholders, and I thought the situation would be worthy of posting. Here is the question, and answer, with permission.

"Hi,

I read your article about minority shareholders. I got an offer to become a shareholder of a small company without paying anything, just because I have been working for them for a period of time.

However, my plans are to go to grad school and then after a year or two look for a position in a large company. Can I then go to work for another company if now I've agreed to become a shareholder of the small company that is just starting? If not, can I, after a year or two, tell that small company that I don't want to be a shareholder anymore? I'm being told by the other shareholders that everything will need to be confidential, so I don't know if my husband and I can show the shareholder agreement to a lawyer."

--------------


First, understand that I am only licensed to practice in North Carolina, and this does not constitute legal advice.

Second, at least in North Carolina, but usually in other states, it is a general industry practice that any agreements which would involve you personally but are labelled "confidential" can still be studied, shared, reviewed by legal counsel before you decide to sign it. Still, the best practice is to let the others know you'd like your personal attorney to review the documents.

Finally, there are two things which may prevent you from joining a big company while still a shareholder of the smaller one. The first is that (assuming their businesses are similar), if you're involved with the smaller company, you owe a duty of loyalty to that smaller venture. If you go to another company, you are not able to use your best efforts for the smaller company. In fact, your actions may go further and violate specific provisions of your shareholders' agreement.

The second issue is also a serious one: what if you just give up your stock rights and leave the company; will that solve everything? There still may be a problem if the remaining shareholders allege that you are using proprietary or confidential information you obtained while a shareholder in the small company. This may specifically violate terms of your shareholder's agreement (which may contain a non-disclosure provision) or it may violate your state's common law rules (i.e., civil rules created by caselaw) regarding what information from your former employer/partnership/venture/etc. that you can use once you leave.

The best thing you can do? Be upfront with the other shareholders, and negotiate a provision that, while protecting their interests, allows you the freedom one day to leave for bigger things: e.g., perhaps an agreement that allows you to leave and join a competing business, but provides that the remaining shareholders can buy out your interest at a fair price (the determination of which would be a subject in itself). If they won't agree to this, both sides are already on notice that there will be a potential conflict in the future--so why buy into it? Either walk away, or understand you may have a fight on your hands when you leave.